Part of the difficulties of dating your college professor was that you couldn’t really do dates close to home – while what they were doing was completely legal, it could still cause them both issues if any student or faculty member recognized them together.

So, usually, they didn’t do dates outside of Sally’s home.

The only time they had, they had made the eight-hour drive to a beach for Sally’s birthday, where they stayed at a hotel for the weekend and spent most of the time in there. He had felt a little guilty because he had been so exhausted from driving that he ended up crashing for the first seven hours there, but overall it had been great and had really been the best weekend of Andrew’s life. It had been a huge deciding factor in realizing that he wanted to be with Sally for the rest of his life.

So yeah, he was pretty jazzed that they were going on a date.

Because Sally didn’t want to drive out of town as she had work tomorrow, it was decided they’d go to see a movie and she’d come in after he and Corey did so there would be no risk of anyone seeing them there.

He and Corey left a little early and walked around the mall for a while, Corey buying Andrew a new jacket since the only one he had was a thin, threadbare hoodie, the two of them talking about all manners of things (but mostly movies and their shared obsession with Game of Thrones). They went to the theater together and Corey bought them candy and two sodas, insisting that Sally could just drink from both of theirs when Andrew tried to buy her one of her own.

They went and sat at the very back of the seats, the theater mostly empty save for a couple other groups and two others that sat alone, and when the ads were just about through, Sally came and joined them. Andrew got up and moved so Sally could sit between them and they stayed like that for most of the movie until Corey went to the bathroom, sitting next to Andrew on his other side when he returned.
Afterward, Andrew and Corey returned home together while Sally went in her own car.

Sally was waiting for them when they got home and very bluntly said she wanted to fuck them, which Andrew appreciated because there was no gray area, and the smirk from Corey gave Andrew enough confirmation that the other man was down for it, which sent his stomach fluttering with anticipation as he remembered the shower they all shared together.

He followed Sally up into the bedroom, and after she gave him a slow kiss, he watched as Sally saunter off into the bathroom. When the door closed he chewed on his bottom lip as he looked back to Corey to see the other man watching him.

“You ready to do this in bed?” Corey asked him in a low, silky tone.

“I guess we’re about to find out,” Andrew said with a little laugh.

Corey smirked at him before he came closer to reach out and start to push the jacket off of Andrew’s shoulders before he pulled Andrew’s shirt up over his head. Andrew met his gaze then and Corey held it as the older man reached down to undo the button on Andrew’s jeans, pulling down the zipper slowly before he pushed his jeans down. “We’ve had a lot of fun tonight, and this is going to be just as great.” He said carefully as he stepped on the jeans between Andrew’s legs, “If you get nervous or feel like you’re intruding, just reach out and grab me and I’ll redirect Sally’s attention back to you, okay?”

Andrew looked to him tenderly. “I want you to have a good time-”

“I won’t have fun unless you get off,” Corey said, cutting him off. “You don’t have to worry about me. I know I’ll have fun.” He said with a smirk.

Andrew flushed and smiled at Corey, whose smirk widened to a smile of his own before he walked Andrew backward out of his jeans to the bed. When Andrew sat down, Corey bent down and stripped him out of his underwear and Andrew shyly crossed his legs. He watched as Corey stripped slowly, the older man staying close as he did so, Andrew nervously looking over Corey as he peeled out of his clothing, one piece at a time.

When he was fully naked, Corey stretched and ran his hand down his bare chest, squeezing one of his swollen pecs briefly before idly scratching at one of his nipples, Andrew watching with a flushed face as Corey rolled it in his fingers with a moan. “You like my pecs?” Corey asked in a low tone, almost a purr. Andrew’s cheeks heated up and he scratched the back of his head sheepishly. “Sally said you liked to suck on her tits…”

“She doesn’t let me,” Andrew said after a dry swallow, his gaze flickering around the room to avoid opening staring at Corey and his impressive muscles, the air in the bedroom heavy with Corey’s scent, a scentless soap and deodorant and his own musky, manly scent. “She says it freaks her out…”

“Well, you’re welcome to suck on these tits.” Corey purred, and when Andrew’s gaze cut back to him, Corey squeezed both of his full pecs, the sight going straight to Andrew’s cock. “Wanna taste?” Corey asked with a smirk.

Before Andrew could summon an answer, Sally came out of the bathroom with a little smile on her face, her heated gaze on Andrew. “Lay down on the bed for me, baby. I was to see you all spread out for me.”

Andrew flushed but nodded, going to slowly lay down on the bed as he watched Sally slowly undo the tie on her robe, opening it up to reveal her naked body, her hands brushing down her full breast and flat stomach before she traced one of the glistening wet lips of her pussy, Andrew shivering as his cock jerked at the sight. She slowly let her robe drag down her back to fall to the floor before she crawled up the bed to part Andrew’s thighs, sitting between them.

Andrew flushed as Sally slid down to place a hot, wet kiss on the tip of his cock and he let out a shuttered breath, rubbing his face with his hand before he used it to cover his mouth. He closed his eyes and leaned his head back as he focused on the wet heat sinking slowly around his cock, moaning lowly as he propped himself up onto his elbows, tilting his head back as his breathing came out in short pants. He saw Corey come onto the bed to get on his knees behind Sally, and he meet the other man’s eyes to see Corey’s was watching him with heavy lids, his pupils blown.

When Corey smirked at him, Andrew dropped his gaze back to Sally before he laid back down and dropped his head on the pillows. Corey watched him still and Andrew flushed under the attention, and when it became too much, he threw one of his arms over his eyes, focusing on the feeling of Sally’s mouth working him in an almost teasing way. Suddenly the heat was gone and he dragged his arm away from his eyes to watch as Sally opened a condom and slowly began to work it down his cock, and when she was finished, he swallowed thickly and watched as she opened his legs wide before she sat up. She placed her hands on his chest and he reached down to loosely hold his hands over hers, watching her slowly sink onto him, squeezing him tight enough to send a thrill of electric pleasure up his spine.

He watched as Corey slid his hands up Sally’s waist to grasp at her breasts, squeezing them in his hands and making her moan as she began to bounce on Andrew’s cock. The sight of it all added with the hot tightness on his cock was almost enough to send him over the edge - it was all so deliciously erotic. He met Corey’s gaze then and Andrew realized that the older man had been watching him the entire time, probably to make sure he was enjoying things. He held Corey’s gaze before it became too intense for him and he dropped it to watch Corey play with Sally’s tits, something she rarely let Andrew do.

But since she was allowing Corey to do that, he figured maybe she was in the mood for it and he sat up, moving to position her hands at his shoulders before he reached up to slid his hands under Corey’s and grasp at her soft, full breasts. He watched as Corey’s hands slid down, one grasping his large, swollen cock to slick it up before he lined it up with Sally’s ass, kneading at it briefly.

Andrew watched as Corey slowly slid into Sally from behind, Sally moaning lowly and loudly as Corey thrust into her, the older woman bouncing harder on Andrew’s cock. Heat pooled in the bottom of Andrew’s belly as Sally stilled, holding him inside of her while Corey continued to thrust in and out of her. Andrew could feel it, Corey’s large cock as it moved inside of Sally, and the feeling was wild, an entirely different sensation that he was used to.

Sally reached up and pulled Andrew’s hands away from her breast then and for a brief second, Andrew had no idea what to do with his hands. But then Corey reached out to pull Andrew flush against Sally, wrapping his arms around the younger man to sandwich Sally tightly between them.

“Fuck me, Andrew,” Sally panted, and Andrew felt suddenly very stupid that he had been uselessly sitting there while Corey was aggressively fucking Sally. Andrew grunted as he began to move his hips, sliding in and out of Sally while Corey thrust with far harder, firmer movements.

Sally reached up and held onto Andrew’s face then to bring their lips together in an insistent kiss and Andrew began to shiver - he tensed and moaned into Sally’s mouth, cumming hard as she squeezed his cock when it was fully inside of her, Corey growing and cursing as he thrust into Sally with enough force that Andrew felt it the entire time he came.

When Andrew finished he went to collapse back onto the bed, but Corey held him to Sally as the older man continued to thrust hard. Andrew shivered and panted as he felt Corey move, Sally moaning into his ear as Andrew softened inside of her. When Corey came, he came with a scream and a slap to Sally’s ass that had her convulsing around Andrew’s soft cock. As he watched her face flush with her orgasm, he reflected on the fact that they never did anything like that – slapping or rough play – because Sally had always told him she could never see him doing something like that.

Maybe it was something she liked...but only with Corey?

Corey ran his tongue over his teeth as he leaned back, pulling out of Sally with an obscenely wet noise before he shifted so Sally could release Andrew, pulling off of his spent cock before she released him so he could lay back down onto the bed.

Andrew shivered hard, reaching up for Sally for a kiss but couldn’t get to her quick enough as she slid off the bed, and after a gentle pat to his hip, she went off to the bathroom to clean up. He looked to the closed bathroom door for a long beat, shivering with his post-orgasm buzz as he waited for her to come back, but instead, he heard the shower running.

A touch to his spent cock brought him back. He felt Corey’s rough, warm fingers gently work the condom off the tender flesh of his cock, Andrew swallowing a whimper as he was finally free from it. He opened his eyes to watch Corey tie it off and toss it to the trash before the older man turned to meet him with a heady look in his eye.

Andrew saw then that Corey wasn’t wearing a condom and he gave him a questioning look.

“I never wear condoms,” Corey said lowly, his voice rough.

“Why?” Andrew asked quietly as Corey slowly laid down next to him, pressing up close to Andrew’s side, his body heat making Andrew shiver all over. It was a little weird but entirely wonderful. He had to fight the urge to try and get the cuddle he so desperately wanted right now from Corey, as he wasn’t sure the older man would be okay with that, and making things weird right now when they were going so well was the last thing he wanted.

“I only fuck Sally in the ass - that’s the agreement. She can fuck whoever she was, but I only get her ass. I’ve always been an ass man, and since she’s the only person I’ve fucked....” He said with a smirk. He leaned down to press a slow kiss to Andrew’s shoulder before he glanced up through his lashes at Andrew’s flushed face. “I think you’re a tits man.”

Andrew laughed a little and settled further into the bed. “Yeah, I think so too.” He said quietly, feeling exhausted from a good orgasm.

“Sally let you play with her tits?” Corey asked just as quietly.

Andrew thought about that for a minute before he shook his head, suddenly feeling a little down that Sally let Corey play with them so easily. Corey made a low noise of acknowledgment before he reached over and took hold of Andrew’s hand, lifting it to place it on one of his heavily muscled pecs with a lazy smirk. “You can play with mine whenever you want. Shower. Bed. Over breakfast.”

Andrew laughed a little before he withdrew his hand, rolling onto his stomach to pull a pillow down and embrace it tightly like he wanted to be embraced. When Corey slid a hand down his naked back he tensed, but only briefly, relaxing under the other’s warm hand and firm but gentle caresses.

“You have a much nicer ass than Sally.” He heard Corey mumble as his hand briefly grazed over one of his ass cheeks before it slide back up his back, and Andrew hummed in response to that, knowing it wasn’t true. Sally had an amazing ass – everything about her body was amazing.

But Corey’s was just as amazing, he thought, only in a different way. Where Sally was soft and feminine, Corey was hard and masculine, and they were both very admirable.

Andrew couldn’t believe his luck that he had such two beautiful people wanting to be with him.

Why would they?

Andrew’s eyes opened and he stared at Corey’s naked chest, watching the way his muscles moved until his skin as Corey continued to rub up and down his back, scratching it gently. Was what they were telling him was true and that they did need him, or were they just...easing themselves back into their marriage after Corey’s long deployment?

Andrew had been sure that it would be Corey one day exiting this three-way relationship, but maybe that wasn’t right at all. Maybe it would be him, pushed out so Sally and Corey could resume their marriage. Today at the mall, he had gotten a real look at how personable and kind Corey could be, and if he was like that with Sally, Andrew could very easily see her falling in love with him again. Though Andrew tried to demonstrate his ability to be a proper partner and an adult capable of taking care of her, Corey had demonstrated to him today that he was already those things and didn’t need to try.

The very thought of Sally deciding Corey was what she wanted and needed had his stomach sinking and suddenly Andrew didn’t feel so relaxed. He felt anxious. Andrew rolled onto his side before he sat up, his back to Corey, whose hand ran down his back before it fell away. Andrew sat there for a beat. “I’m going to go have some time with Sally in the shower.” He said then, sliding off the bed before Corey could say anything.

He shivered off Corey’s unwavering stare as he slid into the bathroom, and when he stepped into the shower next to Sally, he kissed her before he got down on his knees and gave her what he knew she wanted, exactly how she wanted.